EP 193: The Erection Connection

Episode Summary

It’s the Florida February Finale, and we’re going HARD—because somehow, both of this week’s crimes are tied together by boners. Trevin’s free time leads him down a Facebook-induced spiral of existential dread, while Amanda enters her Bridgerton era, only to be deeply troubled...

No murders, just bad decisions.

Listen to the Episode

What This Episode Covers

• It’s the Florida February Finale, and we’re going HARD—because somehow, both of this week’s crimes are tied together by boners.
• Trevin’s free time leads him down a Facebook-induced spiral of existential dread, while Amanda enters her Bridgerton era, only to be deeply troubled by the shift from season one to season two.
• Fast Florida delivers the bizarre tale of Carline Sthilaire, a Florida Woman caught bathing in a puddle outside a library.
• Meanwhile, in Killer Facts, we explore the psychic community of Cassadaga and uncover why Florida crimes are wilder than anywhere else.
• For Storytime, Amanda takes us to The Villages, Florida’s most infamous retirement community, where Reginald "Reggie" Kincer’s pharmaceutical pursuits might just ruin his golden years.
• Then, Trevin tells the story of Deputy Tristan Macomber, a distracted officer whose on-the-job habits turn him into the punchline of his own crime.

Why Listen?

If you like true crime but think most true crime got a little too murdery, this episode brings petty crimes, dumb criminals, and dramatic storytelling without the heavy stuff.

Original Episode Description

It’s the Florida February Finale, and we’re going HARD—because somehow, both of this week’s crimes are tied together by boners.

Trevin’s free time leads him down a Facebook-induced spiral of existential dread, while Amanda enters her Bridgerton era, only to be deeply troubled by the shift from season one to season two.

Fast Florida delivers the bizarre tale of Carline Sthilaire, a Florida Woman caught bathing in a puddle outside a library. Meanwhile, in Killer Facts, we explore the psychic community of Cassadaga and uncover why Florida crimes are wilder than anywhere else.

For Storytime, Amanda takes us to The Villages, Florida’s most infamous retirement community, where Reginald "Reggie" Kincer’s pharmaceutical pursuits might just ruin his golden years. Then, Trevin tells the story of Deputy Tristan Macomber, a distracted officer whose on-the-job habits turn him into the punchline of his own crime.

Pitch a tent and settle in—this Florida-sized finale is one for the books.

Take a break from the heavy and get petty.